Defective Return under Section 139(9) of the Income Tax Act, 1961

A defective return under Section 139(9) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 refers to an Income Tax Return (ITR) that contains incomplete details, incorrect information, or inconsistencies when compared with the records available with the Income Tax Department. When such defects are identified, the taxpayer is provided an opportunity to correct the errors and submit a revised response within a prescribed time, generally 15 days.

Meaning of a Defective Return

An Income Tax Return is considered defective when it does not comply with the requirements of the Income Tax Act. In such cases, the Assessing Officer (AO) issues a notice clearly specifying the shortcomings or errors found in the return.

Common reasons for a return being treated as defective include:

• Incomplete or missing information: Mandatory fields, schedules, or annexures have not been filled or uploaded.
• Mismatch between income and TDS: TDS credit is claimed without reporting the corresponding income, or income is disclosed but related TDS is not reflected.
• Incorrect ITR form selection: Filing an inappropriate return form, such as using ITR-1 despite having business or professional income.
• Non-submission of financial statements or audit reports: Failure to provide Balance Sheet, Profit & Loss Account, or mandatory audit report where applicable.
• Mismatch in tax payment details: Tax paid does not match the declared liability, or challan details such as BSR code or challan number are missing or incorrect.
• Non-verification of the return: The return is not verified electronically or physically within the prescribed time.

Understanding Section 139(9) of the Income Tax Act

Section 139(9) empowers the Income Tax Department to issue a notice if an Income Tax Return is found to be incomplete or incorrect. Upon receiving the notice, the taxpayer is required to rectify the defects and submit the corrected return within 15 days from the date of receipt.

If the taxpayer is unable to comply within the given period, an extension of time may be requested by making a written application to the Assessing Officer. Grant of such extension is subject to the discretion of the tax authorities.

The defective return notice is generally communicated through the taxpayer’s registered email ID and is also accessible on the Income Tax e-filing portal.

Why Is a Defective Return Notice Issued?

A notice under Section 139(9) is not a penalty notice. It is a corrective step taken by the Income Tax Department to ensure accurate reporting of income and proper computation of tax. The provision allows taxpayers to correct genuine mistakes and regularise their return without facing immediate adverse consequences.

How to Respond to a Defective Return Notice

When a defective return notice is issued, the taxpayer must respond within the specified timeframe.

Key points to keep in mind:

• A response must be submitted within 15 days from the date of receipt of the notice.
• All defects mentioned in the notice must be properly addressed.
• If additional time is required, an extension request may be submitted before the expiry of the due date.

Remedy for a Defective Return

Timely rectification is essential once a notice under Section 139(9) is received.

Steps to Rectify a Defective Return:

1. Access the Notice: Log in to the Income Tax e-filing portal and locate the notice under ‘Pending Actions’ or ‘e-Proceedings’.
2. Review the Defects: Carefully analyse the issues highlighted by the department.
3. Rectify the Errors: Prepare a corrected return by updating income details, filling missing schedules, attaching required financial statements, or paying any additional tax, if applicable.
4. Submit the Response: On the portal, choose to agree with the defect and upload the corrected return, or disagree and provide a reasoned explanation with supporting documents.
5. Verify the Response: Complete the process by e-verifying the corrected return using Aadhaar OTP, Digital Signature Certificate, or other prescribed methods.

Time Limit for Rectification

The standard time limit to rectify a defective return is 15 days from the date of receipt of the notice. An extension may be granted at the discretion of the Assessing Officer upon a valid request.

Consequences of Not Responding to the Notice

If the taxpayer fails to rectify the defects within the prescribed or extended time, the original return is treated as invalid, as if no return was filed. This may result in:

• Denial or delay of income tax refunds.
• Levy of interest and penalties on unpaid taxes.
• Inability to carry forward losses to future assessment years.
• Increased risk of scrutiny or further proceedings by the tax authorities.

Conclusion

A defective return notice under Section 139(9) is an opportunity for taxpayers to correct errors and ensure compliance with the Income Tax Act. It does not indicate deliberate non-compliance but highlights gaps that require timely rectification. By carefully reviewing the notice, correcting the defects within the stipulated time, and ensuring proper verification, taxpayers can prevent their return from being treated as invalid.

Regular reconciliation with Form 26AS, AIS, and TIS, correct selection of the ITR form, and thorough verification before filing can significantly reduce the likelihood of receiving such notices. Timely action and accurate reporting remain the key to smooth and compliant income tax filing.

If you have any further questions or need assistance, feel free to reach out to us at admin@ushmaassociates.com or info@nricaservices.com, or contact us via call/WhatsApp at +91 9910075924.

Stay Updated, Stay Compliant!

Disclaimer: Aim of this article is to give basic knowledge about the topic to people who are not in touch with Indian tax norms. When anybody is dealing with these kinds of cases practically, he shall consider all relevant provisions of all applicable Laws like FEMA/Income Tax/RBI /Companies Act etc