Understanding the Difference Between GST and Income Tax

Key Takeaways

• GST is an indirect tax imposed on the consumption of goods and services, whereas income tax is a direct tax based on earnings.
• GST replaces several indirect taxes and is divided into CGST, SGST, and IGST for intra-state and inter-state transactions.
• Income tax funds public services and infrastructure, with distinct forms (ITRs) for different income types and business activities.
• GST returns are filed monthly, quarterly, or annually, while income tax returns are generally filed once a year.
• Failure to comply with GST and income tax requirements results in penalties, interest, and potential legal action.

The Goods and Services Tax (GST) and income tax are both significant taxes in India but serve different purposes in the country’s taxation system. GST is an indirect tax that aims to simplify the tax structure by replacing a variety of previous taxes, while income tax is directly charged on individual and business earnings. Here’s a deeper dive into both taxes to understand their differences more clearly.

What is GST and How Does it Function?
GST is a destination-based tax levied on the sale of goods and services. It replaced numerous indirect taxes, such as service tax, VAT, and excise duty. The primary benefit of GST is the seamless transfer of tax credits among suppliers, reducing the cascading effect of taxes.

GST is divided into three parts:

• CGST (Central Goods and Services Tax): Collected by the central government for intra-state transactions.
• SGST (State Goods and Services Tax): Collected by the state government for intra-state transactions.
• IGST (Integrated Goods and Services Tax): Levied by the central government on interstate transactions.

GST was introduced on July 1, 2017, to streamline the tax system and ensure a unified framework across the nation.

Types of GST Returns
Businesses must file different types of GST returns, depending on their operations. The most common types include:

• GSTR-1: Used to report outward supplies (sales).
• GSTR-2A: An auto-generated form that provides details of purchases.
• GSTR-3B: A summary return detailing sales, purchases, and input tax credits.
• GSTR-4: For small businesses filing quarterly returns.
• GSTR-5: For non-resident Indian taxpayers.
• GSTR-6: For Input Service Distributors (ISDs) distributing ITC.
• GSTR-7: For entities deducting TDS.
• GSTR-9: An annual return summarizing transactions for the previous financial year.
• GSTR-10: For taxpayers cancelling their GST registration.

Filing and Due Dates for GST Returns
The due dates for GST returns depend on the type of return and the taxpayer's revenue. For instance:

• GSTR-1 is due on the 11th of the following month (monthly filers).
• GSTR-3B is due on the 20th of the next month.
• GSTR-9 is an annual return, due by December 31st.

If the taxpayer’s turnover is ₹5 crores or less, they may opt to file quarterly returns instead of monthly ones. Late filing attracts penalties and interest.

Penalties for Non-compliance
Non-compliance with GST regulations can lead to fines, interest, and even imprisonment in severe cases.

• Late filing: A penalty of ₹50 per day (CGST and SGST) or ₹20 for taxpayers not liable for GST.
• Interest: An annual interest rate of 18% on overdue taxes.

Income Tax: What is It and How Does it Work?
Income tax is a direct tax imposed on individuals and businesses based on their annual earnings. The tax is calculated after considering various exemptions and deductions available under the Income Tax Act. Funds raised from income tax are used for public welfare, such as infrastructure development, healthcare, and education.

Types of Income Tax Returns
Depending on their income sources, individuals and businesses must file one of several types of Income Tax Returns (ITRs):

• ITR-1: For individuals earning income through salary, pensions, or interest.
• ITR-2: For individuals with income from capital gains or foreign sources.
• ITR-3: For individuals or Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs) running a business or profession.
• ITR-4: For businesses under the presumptive tax scheme.
• ITR-5: For firms, LLPs, and other entities.

Filing and Due Dates for Income Tax Returns
Individuals and businesses must file their income tax returns within the stipulated deadlines:

• For individuals: The due date is usually July 31st of the assessment year.
• For businesses: The deadline is September 30th.

Returns can be submitted either via paper filing or online through the e-filing portal.

Penalties for Non-compliance
Late filing of income tax returns can result in:

• Fines: Up to ₹10,000.
• Penalties: 50% to 200% of the tax evaded.
• Interest: Interest charges on unpaid taxes.
• Legal action: Repeated non-compliance can result in imprisonment.

Key Differences Between GST and Income Tax Returns

Parameter	GST	Income Tax
Tax Filing	Required when turnover exceeds ₹40 lakhs (for goods) or ₹20 lakhs (for services).	Required when income exceeds ₹2.5 lakhs.
Tax Burden	Passed on to the final consumer.	Paid directly by individuals or businesses.
Coverage	Applies to goods and services across all sectors.	Applies to income from salaries, businesses, and investments.
Tax Rates	Varies depending on goods or services.	Based on income slabs.
Transferability	GST is transferable through input tax credits.	Income tax is non-transferable.

Calculation Differences
The calculation methods for GST and income tax differ significantly. GST is calculated based on the value of supplies (goods and services). Income tax, however, is calculated based on the net income after deductions and exemptions.

Compliance Differences
Both GST and income tax require compliance with specified rules. Non-compliance with GST can lead to penalties, fines, and imprisonment, while income tax violations can result in monetary penalties, additional charges, and potential legal actions.

Are VAT and GST the Same?
VAT (Value-Added Tax) and GST are both indirect taxes, but they differ in their implementation. GST is applicable across India, whereas VAT was a state-level tax. Additionally, VAT applied at different stages of production, while GST applies to the final consumer.

Significant Differences in Filing

• GST requires businesses to file multiple returns throughout the year, depending on turnover, whereas income tax returns are generally filed once a year.
• Businesses with a turnover over ₹40 lakhs (for goods) or ₹20 lakhs (for services) must file GST returns, while income tax must be filed by individuals earning more than ₹2.5 lakhs annually.

Conclusion
Both GST and income tax are essential for the country’s economy, funding infrastructure, healthcare, and public services. Understanding the distinctions between these taxes and ensuring timely filing of returns is critical to avoid penalties and legal complications. Proper adherence to tax rules ensures businesses and individuals can take full advantage of available tax credits, exemptions, and deductions.

If you have any further questions or need assistance, feel free to reach out to us at admin@ushmaassociates.com or info@nricaservices.com, or contact us via call/WhatsApp at +91 9910075924.

Stay Updated, Stay Compliant!

Disclaimer: Aim of this article is to give basic knowledge about the topic to people who are not in touch with Indian tax norms. When anybody is dealing with these kinds of cases practically, he shall consider all relevant provisions of all applicable Laws like FEMA/Income Tax/RBI /Companies Act etc.